BLOG


April 5, 2022

Is there a Difference Between Consequences and Punishment?

Is there a difference between a consequence and a punishment? No. Allow me to explain.

Consequences as we’ve come to know them are a logical punishment for behavior used to teach the child to think the next time before acting. Essentially it is no different than any other form of punishment. These are framed as natural and logical consequences. The problem with a natural consequence is that you cannot give one to someone thus it is natural. It is a natural reaction to a behavior…if you overeat consistently you will get fat. If you work out too hard you will get sore. If you watch Netflix all day when you are done, you will feel hungover. These are all-natural consequences. A person cannot give you a natural consequence. They can say nothing and allow you to experience the natural consequence, but they cannot actually create it.


Logical consequences imply that you are being thoughtful about the consequence and ensuring that it is rational and logical to the behavior. If a child does not eat his dinner, he does not get dessert. If a child goes to school and gets in trouble, then they don’t get to have fun at home. If a child cannot sit at the dinner table and eat what everyone else is eating without complaining, then she is given oatmeal for every meal until she can learn to be appreciative. The problem with logical consequences is that they do not arise from a logical state of mind. The misbehavior has stressed the parent to the point of them needing to regain control. The use of logical consequences for misbehavior is a mechanism of control used to help the parent feel safe under the auspices of good parenting and teaching how to behave. The flaw in the thinking is that we “think” we are being logical when in fact a person in fear of their child’s behavior is in essence stressed and, in the words of neuroscientist Joseph LeDoux, “stress causes confused and distorted thinking and suppresses the short-term memory.” Hence, we keep trying to give children consequences to teach them lessons without realizing that #1 they are stressed therefore their thinking is confused and distorted and their short-term memory is suppressed which means they can neither learn nor remember the lesson #2 We are stressed as the parents and our thinking is confused and distorted and our short-term memory is suppressed therefore we keep trying to teach a lesson that is not being learned and we ourselves cannot remember so we are essentially stuck in groundhog day.


This brings me to my final couple of points: When children are stressed their thinking becomes confused and distorted and their short-term memory is suppressed, and this is where the negative behavior is stemming from. In the moment of stress not only are they not thinking about the possible consequence of their actions, but they can’t even remember the consequence that occurred the last time! Only our parental narcissism leads us to believe that we are so important in our child’s life that in a moment of stress-driven, perceived survival, our threatened consequences would take precedence. Children do not learn from consequences. They learn from repetitive modeling, support, teaching, guidance, and failure!


Finally, we have been led to believe that by giving children consequences we are in fact teaching them responsibility. This is another parenting myth perpetuated by control and fear. As stated previously, one of the primary mechanisms for children to learn is through modeling. Over the years the percentage has been estimated between 80-90% of learning occurs through modeling. When we give a child a consequence it is a reaction to an action. Meaning it requires some form of misbehavior before we give a consequence. This implies reactivity, not responsibility. Thus, we are not actually teaching children responsibility by giving them consequences but rather we are teaching them reactivity! Which is oftentimes the very thing that we are punishing them for since most misbehavior is impulsively driven and is typically a reaction to stress. If we desire to teach children responsibility, we must be willing to take responsibility thereby we become teachers in how to be responsible.


Bryan Post, an adopted and former foster child is one of America’s Foremost Child Behavior and Adoption Experts and founder of www.PostInstitute.com The love-based, family-centered principles and concepts offered by Bryan have been taught to more than one million parents and professionals around the world. You can receive a free copy of his best-selling adoption parenting book From Fear to Love by going to https:///www.feartolovebook.com Currently Bryan serves as Clinical Director for Parents in Training, a 501 (c) 3 non-profit, providing wraparound services to adoptive families throughout Northern California. To learn more visit www.theleafcompany.com

RECENT POSTS


Who Truly Benefits from the Adoption Assistance Program
April 22, 2025
A Closer Look at AAP—Through the Lens of Healing and Support The Adoption Assistance Program isn’t just about financial support—it’s about creating pathways to healing. It’s designed to remove some of the practical barriers that can get in the way of children finding permanent, loving homes. But let’s be clear: this isn’t a handout. It’s a hand-up—for families who are opening their hearts to children who’ve come from hard places. Why AAP Matters Every child deserves the chance to feel safe, to be seen, and to belong. For many children in foster care, trauma, loss, and disrupted attachments are part of their journey. That’s real. The AAP steps in to offer not just financial support, but medical coverage too—because healing takes time, and it takes resources. And sometimes, families need more than just traditional support—they need a team, a village. That’s where Wraparound Services come in. These services create a coordinated plan of care tailored specifically to the needs of the child and the family. It’s about bringing everyone to the table—therapists, teachers, caseworkers, mentors—so the family doesn’t have to carry the weight alone. AAP, when partnered with wraparound approaches, becomes a powerful framework for sustainable, long-term healing. This program exists to support adoptive parents in doing the most important work there is—parenting with love, patience, and understanding, even when the road is rough. Especially then. Who Qualifies? AAP typically focuses on children who’ve been labeled “special needs,” but let’s unpack that a bit. We’re not just talking about medical diagnoses. Special needs can include kids who are older, part of a sibling group, or from racial or ethnic backgrounds that have historically made placement more difficult. These are children who’ve experienced layers of stress and trauma, and they need homes that can meet them where they are. This isn’t about what's “wrong” with the child—it’s about recognizing the impact of their experiences and making sure families have the support to respond with love rather than fear. The Role of Agencies—Public and Private Public child welfare agencies, usually operated by the state, are the primary decision-makers when it comes to AAP eligibility. They assess the child’s history and needs—emotional, physical, developmental—and determine the support required. They’re also responsible for distributing the actual benefits. Private agencies? They’re often the bridge. They help match families with children, walk alongside adoptive parents, and support them through the paperwork and processes. They may not control the funding, but they play a vital role in ensuring the connection between family and child is rooted in understanding. Who’s Eligible for Adoption Assistance? Let’s Look Beyond the Paperwork Understanding What It Really Means to Qualify for AAP When we talk about eligibility for the Adoption Assistance Program (AAP), we’re not just checking off boxes. We’re talking about real children—children who’ve faced uncertainty, trauma, and disruption. And we’re talking about families who are saying yes to the hard work of love, healing, and commitment. The guidelines matter, yes. But what’s more important is why they exist: to make sure no family ever has to say “no” to a child simply because the support wasn’t there. What Does “Special Needs” Really Mean? In the AAP world, “special needs” isn’t a label—it’s a lens. It’s a way of acknowledging the extra layers a child might carry. Maybe it’s a medical diagnosis, or a developmental delay. Maybe it’s being part of a sibling group, or an older child who’s been in foster care for years. These aren’t shortcomings. These are signals that a child has walked a tougher road—and that they’ll need extra support to truly settle into a forever home. In tribal customary adoptions, we honor the cultural roots of Native children, recognizing that “special needs” must be defined through the lens of their community and traditions. And for kids who are part of the juvenile court system, maintaining eligibility means making sure their support doesn’t end just because their paperwork status changes. Every Story is Unique—So is Eligibility Not all adoptions look the same. Some children come from foster care, others from kinship placements. Some are being adopted as nonminor dependents—older teens who still need connection and support, even if they’re close to adulthood. The type of adoption, the child’s age, the prior relationship to the family—all of these influence eligibility for federal or state AAP support. And we can’t forget: the kind of placement a child is coming from—whether foster care or otherwise—can also open or close doors to benefits. This isn’t just policy. This is about whether we set families up to thrive. Let’s Talk About Money—Because That Matters Too Now, income. It’s a tricky subject. Here’s what you need to know: income might affect the amount of support you receive, but it doesn’t usually determine whether you’re eligible in the first place. The system isn’t trying to punish families for what they have or don’t have—it’s trying to make sure the child’s needs are met without putting that weight entirely on your shoulders. And foster care maintenance payments? They often help determine what kind of support you’ll receive through AAP. The goal here is sustainability. We want this to be a journey you can walk with confidence, not fear. Bottom Line: It’s Not Just About Checking Boxes Behind every eligibility guideline is a child—and a family stepping into a sacred responsibility. Understanding the criteria is important, but don’t lose sight of the heart behind it. This is about building safe, loving homes where healing is possible. The AAP is one piece of that puzzle. And together, we can put the whole picture together. How the Adoption Assistance Process Unfolds: A Journey, Not Just a Checklist
The Long-Term Effects of Trauma in Adopted Children
April 21, 2025
Understanding the Impact of Trauma on Brain Development Let’s just take a moment and really lean into this: when children go through trauma—whether it’s a single overwhelming event or a chronic series of unpredictable stressors—it doesn’t just impact how they feel. It rewires their brains. Literally. Trauma affects the very architecture of the brain. Now here’s what I want you to know: we all carry stress, but for our adopted children, especially those who’ve had rocky starts from the womb forward, their brains have been shaped by that stress in deep and lasting ways. We’re talking about fundamental areas of the brain—the hippocampus, the amygdala, the prefrontal cortex. These regions handle memory, emotional responses, and decision-making. When trauma’s been in the driver’s seat too long, these systems go into overdrive. The amygdala? It becomes hypervigilant. Always scanning, always ready to run or fight. That means fear and anxiety become the norm. The prefrontal cortex, the part responsible for impulse control and executive functioning? It can get underdeveloped, and that shows up as difficulty with decision-making, poor judgment, or what some might call “bad behavior.” But we’re not talking about bad kids—we’re talking about stressed-out brains doing the best they can with what they’ve been through. The Impact on Cognitive and Emotional Development Trauma doesn’t just tangle up the brain—it distorts how children see the world and themselves. You may notice delays in language. Struggles with memory. A hard time focusing in school. And here’s the thing: it’s not that they won’t learn—it’s that they can’t , not until their stress system starts to settle. Emotionally, you’ll see it in their relationships. These kids may have a hard time trusting. They may withdraw, or they may explode. It’s not personal. It’s protection. That stress pattern becomes the lens through which they view every interaction. And yet—this is important—it’s not permanent. Healing is possible. The secret ingredient? You . A calm, regulated, loving adult. Someone who creates what I call “oxytocin opportunities”—those moments of deep connection that help regulate a child’s nervous system and say, “You’re safe. You’re loved. You’re not alone.” That’s where healing starts. Not with punishment. Not with control. But with connection. When we show up not to fix, but to be with our kids in their storm, we begin to untangle that trauma, one relationship at a time. Navigating Emotional Challenges in Adopted Children
When to Seek Help: Recognizing Trauma in Adopted Children
April 18, 2025
Let’s talk about something essential—recognizing trauma in adopted children. This isn’t just about a checklist of behaviors; this is about tuning in, with your heart wide open, to the signals your child is giving you. And make no mistake—every behavior is communication. Every reaction, every meltdown, every withdrawal, is your child reaching out, saying, “I need help making sense of my world.” Behavioral Signs and Emotional Disruptions Sometimes that reaching out looks like anger. Other times, it’s withdrawal. Maybe your child lashes out over something that seems small. Or maybe they pull so far inward you barely know they’re there. These are not “bad behaviors.” These are survival strategies. Your child is not broken—they’re doing the best they can with what they’ve lived through. Distrust. Insecurity. Nightmares. Sleep issues. These aren’t just issues—they are trauma symptoms. The body remembers what the brain can’t always verbalize. Sleep disturbances are just one way the nervous system stays on high alert, trying to protect from pain that already passed—but was never processed. And fear? Fear can show up wearing a lot of masks—sadness, irritability, rage. When we start to peel back the layers, what we see isn’t defiance, but a deep emotional wound crying out for connection and safety. Developmental and Learning Challenges Let’s not forget—trauma interrupts development. That’s not just theory. That’s neuroscience. When a child experiences overwhelming, prolonged, or unpredictable stress, it physically alters how their brain organizes itself. So yes, developmental delays are real. They’re not because your child “won’t try” or “just needs more discipline.” They’re because their brain is wired to survive, not thrive—at least until safety becomes the norm. In school, this might look like poor focus or trouble with memory. It might look like academic struggles that don’t seem to make sense. But again, the nervous system is doing its job: staying ready to fight, flee, or freeze. Learning can’t happen until the brain feels safe. That’s the truth.  Post-traumatic stress isn’t reserved for soldiers. Our children live in emotional war zones too. Flashbacks, re-experiencing events, emotional shutdown—these are real symptoms that deserve real compassion. Understanding the Impact of Trauma in Adopted Children

Bringing and keeping families together!

A drawing of a curved line on a white background.